Tourist Alert: Louisiana Revenuers
Deep Sky Webhosting
Want to sponsor a pissedOff forum?

pissedOff logo
home | chat | forums | toons | games | targets | allies | search | archive | legal | who

PREVIOUS | Consciences? We Don't Need No Stinking Consciences! | Strange Logic | Call Off Cursing Police | Libertarian Party Denounces Arrest Of Medical Marijuana Activist Steve Kubby | Will Foster Parole Denied

PISSEDOFF TARGETS Vote for the Top 10 pissedOff Targets updated 2/11
WHAT PISSES YOU OFF? Vent in the expanded pissedOff forums
FREE pissedOff email aliases: limited time offer
SELF-ABUSE pissedOff insult generator
SUBSCRIBE to pissedOff on email

12 - 3 - 97

Tourist Alert: Louisiana Revenuers

by Leon Felkins

Last January, NBC's Dateline aired a story about Louisiana's experiment with "Direct Taxation" of travelers of Interstate 10, which are mostly drug runners (as the cops see it) but may include a few tourists. By Direct Taxation I am referring to that form of taxation that has become increasingly popular in the last few years in which private property is directly seized from the citizens without the usual burdensome legal process. The seizing of property has become a significant portion of the economic support of various government agencies, particularly at the state level.

While I missed that episode of Dateline, fortunately for me and annoyingly to the politicians of Louisiana, they ran the episode again on August 22, 1997, which is where much of the material in this report comes from (see References below). For a short online report, click check out this essay.

The Dateline Episodes

The show starts off with Stone Phillips, one of the more tolerable of the TV Talking Heads, providing this disturbing introduction:

"Imagine a place where Police stop you in your car for no apparent reason and interrogate you. They may seize your property, your money, your car, strip search you and throw you in jail. And you've done nothing wrong. If this sounds like a foreign dictatorship or some Orwellian nightmare, it's not. It's happened right here in America." (Well Stone, you need to get out more often. Actually, when I heard this introduction, the first place I thought of was the USA, where this practice has become a routine practice since the start of the "Drug War" hustle.)

The show goes on with John Larson, NBC reporter, recounting how the Louisiana police routinely stop cars on Interstate 10 (mostly those going west based on the theory that while the drugs go east, the money goes west and catching drug runners is not really all that much fun!). The activity is best illustrated by the event in which Ms. Cheryl Sanders is introduced to the practice:

LARSON: (Voiceover) Cheryl Sanders was on her way to California to visit her mother for Christmas when police stopped her on Interstate 10, claiming she was speeding and had failed to use her turn signal -- what they called improper lane usage. But instead of giving her a traffic ticket, police from the town of Sulfur, Louisiana, took her to jail and made her disrobe.

Ms. SANDERS: I'm standing there naked and she goes through my clothes and checks them all.

LARSON: (Voiceover) Police accused her of being a drug trafficker and ordered her strip searched.

Ms. SANDERS: And for what exactly, for what? For something -- because they wanted my car.

LARSON: (Voiceover) Her car was a white Lincoln Towncar -- all Sanders says she had left from her recent divorce. But citing Louisiana's tough drug forfeiture law, police seized it. The only odd thing is, there were no drugs on Cheryl, no drugs in the car.

Ms. SANDERS: Then they said, 'Well, you're free to go now, but we're keeping your car and find your own way home from Louisiana.'

Mr. TOM LORENZI (Attorney): I never believed that we would get to this point.

LARSON: (Voiceover) Tom Lorenzi is a lawyer who defends many of the people the police pull over.

Mr. LORENZI: The people have this belief that before the state can do something to you it has to prove that you committed a crime, but under the forfeiture law, that's not the case.

LARSON: It's innocent until proven guilty?

Mr. LORENZI: No, it's guilty until proven innocent. What happens now is, without ever having to prove anything, they can take it. Now, it's up to you to come and get it.

LARSON: They don't have to prove anything?

Mr. LORENZI: They don't have to prove anything. They have to prove what they call probable cause. Well, probable cause is precious little, trust me.

LARSON: (Voiceover) In Cheryl's case, probable cause was what police claimed was a false bottom in the trunk of her car -- a small two and a half inch space that police say could have - could have - been used to conceal narcotics.

[Back to Ms. Sanders]

Ms. SANDERS: I've never been in trouble in my life.

LARSON: (Voiceover) There were no narcotics inside, not even a trace. Cheryl had purchased the car used, and says she never saw the compartment. Yet police accused her of a crime: conspiracy to possess over a pound of cocaine. In a court hearing a month later, police admitted they had no evidence.

[. . .]

LARSON: (Voiceover) Cheryl Sanders also decided to fight back. She had to post a bond equal to the value of her car - $7,500, just to begin the process of trying to get her own car back. She took a bus back to Louisiana and hired an attorney. Her legal battle took seven months.

But her fight had been so expensive, she had to sell the car to pay off her legal bills. The only transportation she has left is a bicycle.

(Sanders driving car; Sanders opening garage and walking to bicycle) .

Ms. SANDERS: I can't imagine that this still happens in America. I just can't imagine it.

(While the state couldn't come up with any evidence to prove that Ms. Sanders (or her car) had did anything wrong, it still cost her $4,000 to get her car back.)

Other segments of the show are particularly illuminating in how politicians and police feel about this disgusting activity. Some quotes:

Sheriff EDWARDS: We're not here to violate anybody's constitutional rights. We're -- we are waging a war on drugs.

When Louisiana Governor Mike Foster was asked if he saw nothing wrong with the judges' getting 20 percent of the seized loot, he replied,

Gov. FOSTER: Well, unfortunately or fortunately, in this country, we have to assume that we have an honest judiciary, so I don't see anything wrong with that...You get back to whether you have any -- any trust in the integrity of the law enforcement and the judicial system of the state. I do.

The Rewards of Forfeiture and Seizure

Forfeiture and Seizure has become an increasingly popular activity of the "law enforcement" agencies of both federal and state governments. It has the very lucrative (for the state) characteristic in that the police can take your property with little legal justification or process and it is your problem and your expense to get it back. Published articles on this activity state that typically 80 percent of the cases never go to court -- which is a great savings to the state (and you, the taxpayer!).

Next Segment:

In Part Two of this report I will discuss how the Louisiana government -- bothered by the impact this thuggery might have on the tourist industry (but not about government abuse!) -- went through excruciating pain to try to reform its ways -- and failed.

Appendix: More Examples From the Dateline Episode.


Dateline, NBC News, August 22, 1997. Transcripts of the Dateline series can be obtained by sending $7.00 to Burrelle's Transcripts, Box 7, Livingston, NJ 07039. They also have some video copies of some programs.

The Baton Rouge Advocate published a series of essays on the Dateline story and subsequent maneuverings of the Louisiana politicians. Contact them for copies (there is a small cost).


More of Leon Felkins' essays may be found on his home page, A Rational Life.

What do you think? Add your comments to the bottom of the page
want the email version?
pissedOff enough to write your own rant?

home | chat | forums | toons | games | targets | allies | search | archive | legal | who

copyright 1997 by PO'd Associates LLC. all rights reserved.

Screw the Planet

to: "Tourist Alert: Louisiana Revenuers"

Admin Mode Show Frames Help for HyperNews 1.9.5